Mr Nordic
a view of a city with a lot of snow on the ground

Savour the Flavours of Iceland: Top Spots for Authentic Icelandic Cuisine in Reykjavik

When you plan your trip to the Land of Fire and Ice, don’t miss out on the opportunity to taste the unique Icelandic cuisine. Reykjavik, the capital city of Iceland, is a culinary treasure trove waiting to be discovered. Here’s my list of top places in Reykjavik where you can indulge in authentic Icelandic food.

“Embark on a culinary journey in the heart of Iceland, where Reykjavik’s treasures aren’t just its icy landscapes, but also its fiery, authentic flavours waiting to be discovered.”

Table of Contents

Traditional Dishes of Iceland: A Culinary Journey into Heritage and Local Ingredients

Icelandic cuisine is steeped in tradition and local ingredients, reflecting the country’s rich cultural heritage and environment. One of the most well-known dishes is “Hákarl,” fermented shark that has a distinct, pungent aroma and strong flavor. Another popular dish is “Pylsur,” an Icelandic hot dog made from a blend of lamb, pork, and beef. “Hangikjöt,” smoked lamb, is often served around Christmas time and is a deeply cherished dish.

Hákarl is a traditional Icelandic dish made from a type of shark known as the Greenland shark

“In the heart of Iceland, tradition meets flavor, where pungent Hákarl and hearty Kjötsúpa warm the soul, and a bite of Pylsur or a spoonful of Skyr is like a comforting whisper of home.”

“Skyr” is another Icelandic staple, a creamy dairy product similar to yogurt but with a milder flavor. It’s often served with milk and sugar or used in various desserts. Last but not least, “Kjötsúpa,” traditional lamb soup filled with vegetables and herbs, offers a hearty and comforting meal, especially during the colder months.

Dill Restaurant

Starting the list with the first Michelin-starred restaurant in Iceland, Dill is an absolute must-visit for any food enthusiast looking to embark on a delightful gastronomic journey. Stepping into this culinary haven, you are immediately greeted with a captivating ambiance that sets the stage for an unforgettable dining experience. At Dill, the talented chefs skillfully craft modern interpretations of classic Icelandic dishes, each dish carefully designed to highlight and celebrate the exquisite flavors of locally sourced ingredients.

“Dill, a culinary oasis in Iceland, where every bite is a new adventure, celebrating local flavors with modern flair.”

With a seasonal menu that is constantly evolving, every visit to Dill promises to be a one-of-a-kind adventure, ensuring that no two culinary experiences are ever the same. Prepare to have your taste buds tantalized and your senses awakened as you savor each delectable bite, immersing yourself in the artistry and innovation that defines the essence of Dill.

Matur og Drykkur

Nestled within the walls of a charming, weathered salt fish factory, Matur og Drykkur beckons food enthusiasts with its delightful blend of timeless Icelandic cuisine and contemporary culinary techniques. Embark on a gastronomic adventure as you indulge in the exquisite flavors that await. Delve into the depths of their menu and discover the captivating allure of their cod’s head, lovingly bathed in a rich, flavorful chicken stock, bringing out the inherent succulence of this Icelandic delicacy.

aerial view of city buildings during daytime

“Embark on a food journey at Matur og Drykkur, where timeless Icelandic dishes meet modern cooking. From the succulent cod’s head to the soul-warming lamb soup, every bite is a dance of flavors, a blend of tradition and innovation.”

For those seeking a taste of tradition, the iconic lamb soup stands as a testament to the culinary heritage of this charming Nordic nation. Allow your taste buds to dance to the symphony of flavors as you savor every spoonful of this soul-warming dish. Prepare to be captivated by the harmonious marriage of old and new that awaits you at Matur og Drykkur.


Grillmarkaðurinn, also known as ‘The Grillmarket’, is a sophisticated and upscale steakhouse that takes pride in offering a diverse selection of Icelandic meats such as succulent lamb, tender beef, and even the unique option of horse meat. The restaurant’s commitment to a farm-to-table approach ensures that every dish is prepared with the freshest and highest quality ingredients, resulting in an explosion of flavors that will tantalize your taste buds.

top view, icelandic houses, from the top

“Grillmarkaðurinn, where fresh Icelandic meats meet fiery grills for a feast of flavors that leaves you hungry for more.”

Whether you’re a meat connoisseur or simply looking to indulge in a luxurious dining experience, Grillmarkaðurinn promises to deliver exceptional dishes that will leave you craving for more.

Sægreifinn – The Sea Baron

For seafood enthusiasts who have a deep appreciation for delectable oceanic delicacies, Sægreifinn, affectionately referred to as The Sea Baron, is an absolute must-visit destination. Nestled within the charming streets of the city, this unpretentious eatery has gained immense popularity for its tantalizing lobster soup that is unrivaled in both flavor and richness.

round silver steel bowl with scallops

“Whether you’re wandering the city’s charming streets or hunting its hidden gems, The Sea Baron is a delicious haven. Its unrivaled lobster soup and perfect grilled fish skewers will leave a tasty impression that you won’t forget.”

Additionally, The Sea Baron boasts an exquisite selection of grilled fish skewers that are expertly prepared to perfection, showcasing the culinary prowess of the talented chefs. Whether you find yourself on a leisurely stroll through the vibrant cityscape or embarking on an adventurous exploration of its hidden gems, this humble establishment serves as the ideal haven to satiate your cravings with a quick and mouthwatering meal that will undoubtedly leave a lasting impression on your taste buds.

Íslenski Barinn

Íslenski Barinn, also known as ‘The Icelandic Bar’, is a warm and inviting pub that boasts a delightful selection of traditional Icelandic cuisine. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, this charming establishment is the perfect place to immerse yourself in the rich flavors of the country. One dish that simply cannot be overlooked is the infamous fermented shark. Known for its pungent aroma and unique taste, it is a true delicacy for those seeking a culinary adventure.

cars parked in front of brown building during daytime

“Embrace the flavors of Iceland at Íslenski Barinn. Dive into the unique taste of fermented shark and wash it down with a shot of Brennivin. This is more than a meal, it’s a culinary adventure!”

And if you’re feeling particularly bold, be sure to pair it with a shot of Brennivin, the iconic Icelandic schnapps. This potent beverage is sure to leave a lasting impression on your taste buds. So come and experience the warmth and authenticity of Íslenski Barinn, where traditional Icelandic dishes await your eager palate.

Remember, Icelandic cuisine is much more than just fermented shark and skyr. It’s a culinary journey that reflects the country’s history, culture, and environment. So, come with an open mind and an empty stomach, and let Reykjavik’s best restaurants serve you a slice of Iceland!

Last Updated on August 9, 2023

Mr Nordic

Mr Nordic

I'm a passionate travel blogger captivated by Scandinavia's stunning landscapes, diverse cultures, and Viking history. I explore offbeat destinations in Norway, Sweden, and Denmark, providing authentic insights into Nordic life. When not adventuring, I share my experiences, photos, and love for Scandinavian cuisine. Join me as I uncover Scandinavia's hidden gems and magic!

Subscribe to the Mr Nordic weekly newsletter

Receive the latest articles in your mailbox every week, unsubscribe at any time.

Mailerlite form

About Mr Nordic

Mr Nordic loves the Nordic. He travels all around Denmark, Finland, Iceland, Norway, and Sweden to find the greatest adventures, the most beautifull places and most exciting experiences. Here on you can read all about it. From food to living and from outdoor to culture, Mr Nordic covers it all.